Do yacht clubs really matter in the America's Cup?
According to the Deed of Gift, the basic set of rules that govern the America's Cup, "any organized yacht Club of a foreign country, incorporated, patented, or licensed by the legislature, admiralty or other executive department, having for its annual regatta an ocean water course on the sea, or on an arm of the sea, or one which combines both, shall always be entitled to the right of sailing a match for this Cup". In the 32nd edition of the world's oldest sailing event, a few exceptions were granted. The Spanish challenged through their national sailing federation, the Chinese through the newly-created Qingdao International yacht Club, while finally the Germans opted as well for a previously non-existent club.
Then in June 2007, Alinghi lowered the bar even further and together with their sinister bedfellows, the then President and Vice President of the Spanish Sailing Federation, Gerardo Pombo and Manuel Chirivella, created the Club Nautico Español de Vela (CNEV) in a week in order to have a hip-pocket challenger of record for the 33rd Cup. Although duly registered as a yacht club, the CNEV didn't exist beyond paper. BMW Oracle filed a lawsuit and the rest is history.
Start of the first race of the 2010 Aleph Cup. La Grande Motte, 27 November 2010. Photo copyright Aleph Yacht ClubHowever, and despite its rhetoric during the long and tedious legal battle of the 33rd America's Cup, the current Defending yacht club, Golden Gate Yacht Club, accepted and validated on Friday, December 10th, a formal challenge by a yacht club that is a barely a month old (officially registered on November 4th) and held the first edition of its annual regatta just two weeks ago, on November 27th.
We are referring to the newly-created Aleph Yacht Club that will be represented by Aleph Team France, the team headed by Bertrand Pacé and Alain Gautier. I think this is another proof that the yacht clubs are mere technicalities and the organizers focus instead on the credentials of the project rather than the underlying club and of course you could hardly get stronger credentials in France than the duo Pacé-Gautier. The yacht club, obviously, meets the criteria set by the Deed of Gift, but just the strict minimum.
The offices of Aleph Yacht Club are in Paris and their regatta was held at the premises of the Yacht Club de La Grande Motte (YCGM) in southern France. This is understandable since the French capital is not anywhere near an "ocean water course on the sea, or on an arm of the sea". It's puzzling though that not one single member of the club took part in their first ever annual regatta, as per the score table!!
Maybe that's why the America's Cup is still at the pinnacle of our sport and if they ditch that antiquated rule they might just become another circuit like the Volvo Ocean Race or the AUDI Medcup.
Labels: 33rd America's Cup, 34th America's Cup, Aleph Team France, BMW Oracle
18 Comments:
Coutts Ehman and co have really no pride. They have the guts to accept what they fought during two years in court. And saying CNEV was the CoR is crap. What difference does it make?
Another proof GGYC should be relieved from its duty of Trustee.
But when you are in lack of challengers, you suddenly feel many things become suddenly acceptable.
Lot of words, but little logic, sorry...
@ 4:37 PM anon
BMWOracle can not just, at free will, reject entries that they do not "like". As long as the entry is deed legal and the required entry fee is beeing paied they have to accept the entry.
Great spot you Flintstone. I'm sure that the Defender made sure the annual regatta HAD been HELD before the paperwork was submitted, just to get another boat on the starting grid.
Don't worry yourself about the Deed of Gift. This is do as I do, not as I say.
7:46
Am supporting Aleph entry. Fully. Just saying BOR takes a very different stand from what they had when opposed to ALinghi.
I am specially happy to see how BOR is smashing the same strategy than Alinghi but well done.
AC's been always like this.
It must hurt Ernesto, eh?
Pisha
i wish Alinghi were still doing those cartoons they could have a field day with the way these guys are behaving. Pierre why don't you start a series?
Alinghi didnt handle the CNEV situation too well, I think EB even admitted that.
ML is as much of a hip-pocket challenger as CNEV was, maybe even more some because we expected more from ML.
You can trust GGYC and BOR lawyers to clearly make the difference between a Deed legal yacht club and an illegal one can't you?
I don't see any optimist on your picture.
9:58 AM
Why??
CNEV was not deed legal
Aleph is.
That is a BIG difference, isn't it?
what a bunch of useles milloners!!
is that the only think they can come up with to have another name as a challenger? we will see when the moment of true comes...the moment of paying the fee how many will participate. nice job larry!!
you went to court, won, and just changed the name of the players!!
so much money so little pride...
CNEV was the COR and had not held their annual regatta prior to be accepted as said COR. To top it off, when they attempted to hold a first "annual" regatta, they did so in dinghy's sailed by kids. Say what you want about the Aleph YC, but at least they held a proper regatta prior to being accepted as a mere challenger.
Regardless, as always, haters gonna hate.
CNEV, CNR and Aleph have the same content but differents shapes... They are not old and prestigius YC... BOR must be more carefully
There is a distinct difference between the COR and any other challenge, contrary to stated here, anyone other than the COR is only there at the sufferance of the defender and the COR there is no right to a challenger series.
As any other rule can be waived by mutual agreement, so can the requirements for an entry into the challenger series (how did Alinghi get in the first time for example).
Perfectly legit under both the deed and historically, unlike CNEV which was not a valid COR, but quire possibly could have been allowed to compete by mutual agreement by a legitimate COR.
6:10 PM anon
"They are not old and prestigius YC...BOR must be more carefully"
...and you need to learn read the deed of gift more carefully...
It all just proves what a stupid document the DOG is in todays world and how it can be manipulated by a deffender and "friendly" COR.
The only good thing about all this is that it has exposed BMWOR's strategy since 2007 and I bet there are a few AC Teams that are regretting having sided with them when they screwed Alinghi through the courts. There's a good chance ETNZ could have won the 33rd AC as proposed by Alinghi now they have next to no chance.
I can see that Jean Marie Vidal has entered the annual regatta. Does that mean that Aleph will be based in Port Camargue?...
3:11 AM anon
Your comments just prove that you understand very little about the deed of gift and the America's Cup
Post a Comment
<< Home